Thursday, April 21, 2011

Proponents predict wave of turbines

Hundreds of tidal generators could follow prototypes into Bay of Fundy


Tidal power proponents envision hundreds of electricity-generating turbines being installed in the Bay of Fundy within five years of the deployment of four prototypes.

Those prototypes are scheduled to be placed in the Minas Basin before the end of 2012.

After that, "we’re expecting we’ll be able to follow a similar deployment and monitoring approach to the one we are employing in northern Scotland," Joseph Fison, director of corporate development for Atlantis Resources Corp., said Wednesday.

"After four or five years, we could have hundreds of turbines in the water."

Fison made the comment after giving a presentation at the Renewable Energy Conference 2011 in Halifax.

Atlantis Resources plans to install a version of its AK1000 turbine in the Minas Basin in the summer of 2012 with partners Lockheed Martin Canada and Irving Shipbuilding.

Fison said Lockheed Martin will provide engineering and procurement services, while Irving will manufacture the turbine base in Halifax before it is floated to the Bay of Fundy.

He told conference participants that future developments could happen quickly if Atlantis Resources is selected for more deployments.

"We would move as quickly as regulatory approvals could be obtained," he said.

Fison said a recent test of an AK1000 turbine off the coast of Australia, located near a large breeding ground for penguins, demonstrated that the huge underwater generator could co-exist with marine animals.

Minas Basin Pulp and Power and Alstom of France are also planning to install turbines in the basin in 2012.

There is a possibility the $10-million turbine removed from the Bay of Fundy by partners OpenHydro of Ireland and Nova Scotia Power Inc. last year will be repositioned in 2011 or 2012.

The turbines will be connected to subsea transmission cables installed by Fundy Ocean Research Centre for Energy, which is leading the project.

Acadia University researcher Richard Karsten said computer modelling indicates a deployment of 2,000 tidal turbines in the Minas Basin area of the Bay of Fundy is reasonable from an ecological point of view.

The modelling indicates that many turbines would result in minimal change to the tidal action in the basin but he said more study needs to be done.

"We do not want to have green power that is not green," Karsten said. "We want to take advantage of the tidal currents without destroying them."

Several hundred people from the renewable energy sector attended the two-day conference in Halifax that concluded Wednesday.


http://thechronicleherald.ca/Business/1239570.html

Saturday, April 9, 2011

N.S. factors Lower Churchill into 40% renewable energy goal


The proposed undersea hydroelectric cable linking Newfoundland and Labrador to this province would help Nova Scotia reach its goal of getting 40 per cent of its power from renewable sources by 2020, the provincial energy minister says.

Charlie Parker introduced the Clean Energy Act on Friday, a bill that would include hydroelectricity as one of the sources counting toward the green energy targets set for the next nine years.

"This target . . . represents (the) transformation of our energy sector from one that is largely dependent on imports of dirty coal to one built on the foundation of clean, renewable resources from our own backyards," Parker said in his speech.

The proposed $6.2-billion Lower Churchill development could produce about 10 per cent of Nova Scotia’s electricity, if the project is completed on schedule by 2017, the minister said. That would account for about a quarter of the 40 per cent renewable energy commitment.

The hydroelectric power project is now undergoing an environmental evaluation.

Several members of the Senate energy committee questioned whether the project could realistically be finished by 2017, The Canadian Press reported when the committee met in Halifax last month.

Nova Scotia Power CEO Rob Bennett said then that the timeline could be met because Newfoundland’s Crown utility has been developing the project for more than 20 years.

The Liberal party’s energy critic found fault with the act.

"There is no goal in this legislation," Andrew Younger said. "It adds the word ‘hydroelectricity’ to the act. In terms of the goal, they’re going to put it in a cabinet order, which they can change at a whim if Churchill Falls doesn’t come through."

The Lower Churchill development would not be the only way to meet the 40 per cent target, but it would be the most affordable, Nova Scotia Power’s vice-president for sustainability said.

"There’s always renewable resources, (but if) it’s a question of the cost . . . we think (Churchill) is the best thing for customers," Robin McAdam said.

Nova Scotia Power has a 20 per cent stake in the Lower Churchill project, which guarantees it receives 170 megawatts of firm and flexible power annually for 35 years. The power will be delivered from the hydroelectric dam in Labrador through an undersea cable.

Progressive Conservative Leader Jamie Baillie said Parker’s bill would help the province move from coal-powered electricity to more sustainable forms of energy.

"Having said that, the legislation is silent on economic goals and I think it’s important that we not lose sight of the economic opportunity that Lower Churchill presents," he said.

Parker’s bill still has to be debated in the legislature before it becomes law. Even then, the change to the act would not hold Nova Scotia Power accountable to the 40 per cent target. To do that, the province would have to amend the province’s renewable energy regulations; currently, there are only regulated targets for 2011, 2013 and 2015 — at five, 10 and 25 per cent.

An Ecology Action Centre spokesman commended the province for setting the 40 per cent target but said he wonders if the required infrastructure will be in place to meet it.

"Relying heavily on renewable energy projects in other provinces to meet those targets could come back to be a problem here," Brennan Vogel said.


http://thechronicleherald.ca/Front/1237547.html

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Amherst: Stalled wind project moving forward

Published on March 2, 2011

Darrell Cole

Amherst Daily News


AMHERST - A stalled wind project near Amherst has been given a new lease on life with the purchase of the project's assets by an Ontario company.

Sprott Power of Toronto is in the midst of purchasing the Amherst wind project from Acciona that was awarded the contract by Nova Scotia Power in 2008 to generate 30 megawatts of power through a wind farm on the marsh just outside town.

"We're just in the process of getting all the required consents transferred to us," Sprott Power CEO Jeff Jenner said. "It's an attractive project in that it has been worked on over a number of years and in our mind it's a near or ready-to-construct project that was available."

Sprott, headquartered in Toronto, is a relatively new player in the wind energy industry, but its executives bring lots of experience from working with Vestas Energy.

Acciona announced in May 2008 that it was investing $55 million in the wind farm that could include 20 turbines. The project ground to a halt in March 2009 when Acciona said it was not in a position to continue because liquidity for large capital projects was tight and that the Amherst project was extremely capital intensive.

Jenner said his company plans to erect 15 turbines on the marsh with each turbine being about 90 metres in height.


http://www.amherstdaily.com/News/Local/2011-03-02/article-2295650/Stalled-wind-project-moving-forward/1

Sunday, February 13, 2011

Ontario stops offshore wind power development

RICHARD BLACKWELL

Globe and Mail Update


The Ontario government has called a stop to any offshore wind power projects in the province’s portion of the Great Lakes, until further scientific study is done.

In an announcement that stunned both wind power supporters and opponents, the province – which has strongly supported a shift to renewable sources of power – said Friday that it will not proceed with any offshore wind projects “while further research is conducted.”

No offshore wind projects had yet received full approvals, but several were in the planning stages and one had already received a contract to sell electricity to the province under the “feed-in-tariff” program that pays high prices for renewable power. That contract will be cancelled, applications will be suspended and no more will be accepted, the province said.

Some of the proposed projects, including one in Lake Ontario just off the Toronto suburb of Scarborough, and another near Kingston, had raised the ire of local residents who did not want their view of the lake interrupted by a string of wind turbines.

The government noted that producing power from offshore wind farms in freshwater lakes is early in the development stages, and there are no projects operating yet in North America. There is one in place in Sweden, and a pilot project has been proposed in Ohio, it said.

“We will be working with our U.S. neighbours to ensure that any offshore wind projects are protective of the environment,” Ontario Environment Minister John Wilkinson said in a statement. “Offshore wind on freshwater lakes is a recent concept that requires a cautious approach until the science of environmental impact is clear. In contrast, the science concerning land-based wind is extensive.”

Ontario currently generates about 1,500 megawatts of power from land-based wind farms.

The province halted offshore wind projects once in the past. In 2006 it put a moratorium on any offshore development while it examined environmental issues, but it was removed early in 2008.

There are already hundreds of offshore wind farms in place in ocean waters, mainly off the coasts of European countries

The wind industry was taken aback by Friday's announcement.

“It is an unfortunate decision because Ontario has been working to position itself as a leader in this sector,” said Robert Hornung, president of the Canadian Wind Energy Association, which represents developers and wind hardware manufacturers. The decision obviously creates uncertainty for the industry, he said, although he expressed hope that it represents merely a “pause” in development. CANWEA will try to help the government conduct its research, he added.

Wind power opponents said Ontario’s decision shows there are real environmental concerns about turbines, although they would have liked to see a stop to land-based development as well.

“It is a victory and it validates our position,” said John Laforet, president of the lobby group Wind Concerns Ontario. Government officials in the past characterized his group’s opposition to offshore turbines as “absurd,” he said. “This demonstrates they don’t know what they are doing and they are scared [of the political fallout], which they should be. They understand they have a political problem and the science is not on their side.”

The Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment, a group that has supported wind power and other renewables, said it was disappointed with the decision but is “heartened” by the fact that the province is still committed to eliminating coal-fired power plants.

The Society for Wind Vigilance, which wants far more study on the health impacts of land-based turbines, said it would like a moratorium on all industrial wind developments. “The Ontario government admitted on Friday that more scientific research needs to be done before proceeding with industrial wind turbines in the Great Lakes and other freshwater bodies,” said spokeswoman Beth Harrington. “What is clear from our research of industrial wind development on land is that not nearly enough research has been done to protect human health.”

Ontario’s opposition energy critic, John Yakabuski, called the government’s move “a spectacular backtrack.” He said the Liberal’s green energy plan has been “oversold from the start” and it was “never properly planned.”

The Conservative party feels there is no need for offshore wind farms, Mr. Yakabuski said. Other forms of renewable energy “must be a rates that families and small businesses can afford and [projects] must be in communities that welcome it.”


http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/industry-news/energy-and-resources/ontario-stops-offshore-wind-power-development/article1904138/

Ontario scraps offshore wind power plans

Back to Ontario scraps offshore wind power plans

February 12, 2011

Tanya Talaga

The Toronto Star



The provincial government has suddenly abandoned any plans to construct offshore wind projects.

Citing environmental concerns, the Liberals made the surprising announcement Friday that they have placed a moratorium on building wind power projects in freshwater lakes.

While there are currently no offshore wind projects anywhere in Ontario, the issue has been a political problem for the Liberals as the October election inches closer and seats in rural areas are up for grabs. Anti-wind activists living along the Scarborough Bluffs also vigorously oppose any plans to construct offshore wind farms in Lake Ontario.

Activist voices have dogged Premier Dalton McGuinty when he travels to rural communities where wind turbine projects have been installed or are planned.

They say the low-frequency noise from the turbines causes health problems such as nose bleeds and headaches.

The premier has argued the push for wind is needed as Ontario phases out coal-fired plants and the push is made toward a green energy economy.

A Liberal insider confided that officials scrambled to announce the climbdown shortly after noon Friday when they realized it would be buried by the news from Egypt.

On Saturday, a senior adviser to McGuinty, said the timing of the announcement was determined earlier and had nothing to do with events overseas.

“You can take a shot at us for announcing it on a Friday, but the Egypt stuff is ... just false,” said the high-ranking official.

But Energy Minister Brad Duguid denied the move was politically motivated. He said it was done for environmental reasons.

“There isn’t a lot of science on freshwater offshore wind while there is tons of science on land wind farms,” Duguid told the Star.

Building offshore wind turbine projects in freshwater lakes is early in development and there are no projects in North America, he added.

There is one pilot project in Sweden at Lake Vanern and another has been proposed in Ohio.

“We need some time to review the science and we don’t have it today,” he said.

The Liberals will not back down on their land-based wind turbine projects, he added. “We have shown a lot of leadership on the energy file and we haven’t backed away one bit from tough decisions,” he said. “Our generation has to think of our responsibility here … to get out of coal, get cleaner air and provide a healthier future for our kids.”

Anti-wind activists called the reversal a victory.

John Laforet, president of Wind Concerns Ontario, called the move “excellent” but said the Liberals don’t care about the environment.

“If they cared for it they wouldn’t be allowing on land projects either,” Laforet said, adding he’s watched wind projects go up after forests have been blasted down.

“I think what they have realized is they have unleashed hell on themselves before an election and we aren’t going away,” he said. “One side of me feels vindicated in being a volunteer in this role … but at the same time I don’t believe for a second these guys care for the environment.”

Opposition critics called the announcement a spectacular policy backtrack.

The entire green energy act was founded on political science, not actual science, said Progressive Conservative energy critic John Yakabuski.

“This is a complete admission that these guys have a failed energy policy and never went through the proper planning in the first place,” said Yakabuski (Renfrew-Nipissing-Pembroke).

“Everything these people do is based on whether or not it will get them votes.”

Pausing wind turbine projects proves the government is making a laughingstock of itself, said NDP energy critic Peter Tabuns (Toronto-Danforth).

“It’s entirely possible this is a decision based entirely on saving a few seats,” Tabuns said.

“They flip-flopped on the Oakville gas plant and now there’s another big reversal from Brad Duguid,” Tabuns added of the energy minister, who cancelled plans to build the natural gas-powered electricity plant last October saying it was no longer needed. “They’re turning their backs on everything they’ve said.”

Offshore projects are merely a fraction of the government’s renewable energy plan, Duguid added.

So far, 1,530 feed-in-tariff applications for mostly wind and solar projects have been received by the government to date but less than five were for offshore wind projects, he said.

And only one offshore contract in Kingston with Windstream has been accepted out of the almost 1,300 approved contracts, Duguid said.

“That one project contract won’t be cancelled, it’ll be extended until the science is done,” Duguid said.

Jeff Garrah, CEO of the Kingston Economic Development Corporation, said he was “shocked and horrified” to find out that the offshore project in his area was suddenly on hold.

“We’ve worked with various offshore supporters for about a year,” he said, adding the overall loss is about 1,900 jobs in five years.

“This sends a distorted message to outside investors in Ontario when a company is offered a contract, Windstream, and the province reneges on it.”

Gideon Forman, the executive director of the Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment, said the move is a bit of a setback but not a fatal blow for wind power.

“We don’t think it’ll fundamentally change anything,” he said. “We knew there was a five-kilometre setback with offshore projects but we didn’t think they’d scrap the whole thing. This seemed to come out of nowhere.”

What is important is the continued Liberal commitment to onshore wind projects and the phaseout of coal-fired plants, he added.

“The key thing for protecting human health for us is phasing out coal,” he said.

With files from Robert Benzie and Rob Ferguson


http://www.thestar.com/news/ontario/article/937358--ontario-scraps-offshore-wind-power-plans

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Electrical problem expected as cause in windmill fire

Published on January 31st, 2011
The New Glasgow News
Sueann Musick

MILLSVILLE – Trenton resident Doug Stewart knew something was wrong early this morning when he pointed his binoculars towards his sister’s house in Millsville and saw nothing but black smoke.

Stewart, who lives near the Trenton Airport, said he is often bird watching and looking at the windmills on Fitzpatrick Mountain, but instead of spotting blades and towers 32 kilometres away, all he saw was smoke.

“I am always looking that way and it didn’t look too bright this morning,” he said. “It was quite black.”

Stewart called the RCMP who told him he was the second person to report the smoke. He also called his sister Donna Sutherland, who lives two kilometres away from the windmills, to see what was happening.

“I didn’t notice it at first,” she said. “There is a spruce tree in the way so I had to go outside and take a look. Once I walked outside, I saw the smoke.”

Central West River resident Kevin Hawkes said he knew there was a problem when he saw black smoke while driving home from work early yesterday morning.

“I went home and grabbed my camera but it was about 15 or 20 minutes before I got there,” he said. “By then it was pretty much out.”

Scotsburn Fire Department arrived on the scene at Tower Road in Millsville about 7:30 p.m. yesterday after someone working at the site reported smoke coming from the motor compartment of the wind turbine.

The turbines are owned by Shear Wind Inc. and were constructed on Fitzpatrick Mountain about four years ago.

Ian Tillard, chief operating officer for Shear Wind, said it took about an hour for the fire to burn itself out. In such cases, he said, the turbines are designed to stop and de-energize so there is little the fire department needs to do other than keep the area clear underneath it.

Tillard said the Scotsburn Department responded in record time and provided the support the company needed, but he acknowledged the company will have to work with local firefighters in the future about responding to such situations.

“We have done a lot of work with fire departments near the Glen Dhu site and it’s apparent we need to do that with the Scotsburn Fire Department,” he said. “Fires like this are extremely rare on these units, but there are concerns in the summer with forest fires and public safety.”

Tillard said the area around the damaged windmill has been cordoned off and the local snowmobile club has been notified since there are some trails on the site.

He suspects the fire was electrical in nature, but won’t know the exact cause until it is investigated by the company. He said the components damaged by the early morning fire will be replaced.


http://www.ngnews.ca/News/Local/2011-01-31/article-2187158/Electrical-problem-expected-as-cause-in-windmill-fire/1

Nuttby Mountain wind turbines cracked

From CBC News

Last Updated: Tuesday, February 1, 2011 | 5:03 PM AT


Nearly all of the 22 turbine foundations at Nova Scotia Power's Nuttby Mountain wind farm are cracked, CBC News has learned.

"Wherever we identify cracks, they are being addressed. I think right now we are at 19 of the 22," NSP spokesman David Rodenhiser said Tuesday.

The problem came to light late last year when it was discovered five of the towers were moving beyond manufacturers specifications.

During construction last July at the $120-million wind farm, concrete was not vibrated down to the steel base of the towers.

Movement with the remaining towers is within acceptable tolerance levels, Rodenhiser said, but NSP decided to repair them anyway.

"We've found some cracking in some of the other foundations ... we decided the most prudent measure was to address those as well," he said.

The repairs involve injecting an epoxy-like sealant into the 400-tonne concrete pads to stabilize the concrete.

The German supplier, Enercon Canada Inc., supplied the turbines and is paying for the repairs, which are covered under warranty.

"It is my understanding that there was vibration and tamping that did not get done to the extent that the concrete settled all the way to the bottom of the steel," Rodenhiser said.

It will be well into March at the earliest, before the repairs are completed.

As the foundations are repaired, towers will be brought into service generating electricity for the provincial grid.

"The towers have been generating electricity," Rodenhiser said.