Sunday, October 24, 2010

Why PEI’s wind plan is dying

RICHARD BLACKWELL

CHARLOTTETOWN— From Tuesday's Globe and Mail


In October, 2008, Prince Edward Island Premier Robert Ghiz made a bold promise. The province was going to dramatically increase the amount of wind power it produced, boosting production to 30 per cent of its total electricity consumption from the 18 per cent it then generated.

The move would make the province a green powerhouse, and the North American jurisdiction with by far the highest proportion of wind-generated electricity. At the same time, PEI would become an energy exporter – despite having no other homegrown sources of power – by building additional wind projects to sell power into the New England market.

All this was to be accomplished by 2013, when the province would have 500 megawatts of wind turbines churning out power – a substantial amount for a tiny island province. Only Ontario, Quebec and Alberta would have had more.

Mr. Ghiz vowed that the $1-billion worth of wind farm and transmission construction would be the largest project on the island since the building of the Confederation Bridge.

Two years later, the plan is in disarray. While PEI tried to attract private developers to the province, several of their proposals demanded higher power prices than the province was willing to pay. The government and its utility rejected the offers because they would have driven up electricity prices, which are already the highest in Canada.

Currently, the government is in negotiations with two developers to build projects that will add just 30 MW to the 164 MW of wind power already in production in the province.

PEI’s tarnished vision underlines the delicate economics of renewable energy around the world, where subsidies and high energy prices are often the keys to getting projects off the ground.

While there is tremendous pressure on governments to wean their power grids off fossil fuel, renewables are still an expensive alternative that can push up electricity prices. There is also an increasing public pushback against huge turbine developments – or other “clean” generation projects – near populated areas, forcing politicians to think twice. Just last week, the Ontario government backed down on a proposed natural-gas-powered electricity plan in the populous – and wealthy – Toronto suburb of Oakville, after a well-organized and intense public protest.

In PEI’s case, a key problem was that expected North American “cap-and-trade” carbon-pricing policies did not come to pass, Energy Minister Richard Brown said in an interview at his office in Charlottetown. If they had, carbon credits associated with wind power would have made development on PEI much more viable, he said.

At the same time, the plunge of the global economy into recession didn’t help. “Economic conditions went down the tubes, and that opened up a lot of excess [power generation] capacity,” Mr. Brown said. Consequently, energy prices dropped, making wind less viable.

Still, “the plan is not dead ... we are still committed to 500 MW of wind,” Mr. Brown insists. The time frame has merely been extended until the economy turns around and energy prices make wind projects more viable. “Any developer that wants to come forward with a project on Prince Edward Island, I am more than pleased to entertain [their plans],” he said.

PEI’s plan was formulated at time when oil prices were above $100 (U.S.) a barrel, noted Dinara Millington, a senior economist with the Canadian Energy Research Institute in Calgary. But that didn’t last. “They did not foresee these kinds of issues, with the economy being so depressed and prices for fossil fuel energy being so low,” she said. That removed any incentives for private developers to jump in with big projects.

Essentially, unless energy prices show substantial and sustainable increases, in most jurisdictions wind power is not economical without subsidies of some sort, Ms. Millington said.

The dilemma for PEI is that if it pays too much to wind developers, electricity prices for consumers and businesses will have to go up, and some of those businesses may leave the island as a result, damaging the overall economy.

By contrast, Ontario can pay high “feed-in tariffs” for the wind and solar power it buys from developers because those renewables still make up just a tiny proportion of that province’s power generation and thus put less upward pressure on overall electricity prices. Even in Ontario, however, the shift to renewables has raised the spectre of higher power prices over the longer term.

“I’ve had developers come in here and say ‘well I can go to Ontario.’ ” Mr. Brown said. “My comment to them is, ‘If Ontario is offering a better deal, see you later.’ ”

Indeed, Ontario currently pays 13.5 cents per kilowatt-hour for on-shore wind power, while PEI pays just 7.75 cents. That makes PEI far less attractive, unless a developer can export some of its power at a much higher price.

With 22 per cent of PEI’s electricity currently generated by wind, “we’re already a world leader in renewable energy,” Mr. Brown said, but he’s not willing to push those numbers higher if it means subjecting islanders to higher rates.

Transmission is also an issue, if PEI is to become a bigger wind energy exporter. Currently, undersea cables carry power to the province from New Brunswick, and some wind power (from a privately owned wind farm) off the island. But that capacity is limited.

The federal government needs to help finance new transmission lines, Mr. Brown said, but Ottawa should also be taking the lead in creating a better east-west power grid that connects the provinces together. The current situation, where most provinces connect north-south to U.S. states, is inefficient and counterproductive to Canada’s energy and environmental interests, he said.


http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/industry-news/energy-and-resources/why-peis-wind-plan-is-dying/article1752506/

Wednesday, October 20, 2010

NSP, Daewoo ink deal on wind power


Nova Scotia Power and Daewoo Shipbuilding and Marine Engineering have agreed to build and use made-in Nova Scotia wind towers and blades across the province.

Premier Darrell Dexter says his government has signed a letter of intent that provides the opportunity for Daewoo to supply wind turbine components for up to 100 megawatts of capacity over the next four years.

The Nova Scotia government is a partner with Daewoo to build a wind turbine plant at the former TrentonWorks railcar factory.

Nova Scotia Power will work with Daewoo on having the Trenton plant supply the towers and blades required by the utility during the next several years.

The private utility company will also encourage the use of those components by independent power producers working on their own or in partnership with communities. Under the letter of intent, Daewoo would supply Nova Scotia Power with the wind turbine components, subject to competitive pricing and quality, and the ability to meet requirements of the utility’s turbine suppliers.


http://www.thechronicleherald.ca/Business/1207865.html

Power rate discussion being held in the dark

Hearings on latest NSP hike mostly behind closed doors

Nova Scotians are being asked to pay an additional $7 per month for electricity starting next year but the public isn’t getting to hear much of the evidence.

The second day of public hearings into the rate increase were mostly held behind closed doors before the provincial Utility and Review Board, which sets power rates in Nova Scotia.

If approved, this will be the sixth power rate increase in nine years, with the average residential customer paying $244.08 every two months to keep the lights on, according to Nova Scotia Power.

Several consultants criticizing the proposed rate increase for homeowners and businesses testified in camera to the three board members hearing the case.

Other information about Nova Scotia Power’s coal contracts, the utility’s credit rating and mercury emissions were also marked confidential for only lawyers, consultants and board members to view.

One consultant testified Nova Scotia Power shareholders should pick up the tab for the utility ordering excessive amounts of coal in 2009, which resulted in higher carrying charges.

"I stand by my analysis of the costs borne by customers due to additional coal handling costs incurred in 2009 and would ask the board to consider that a portion of those cost should be borne by NSP and not the ratepayer base," Colin Gubbins, a U.K. coal consultant with McCloskey Group, told the board Tuesday.

He was hired by two of the province’s largest consumers of electricity, paper giants NewPage Port Hawkesbury and Bowater Mersey, which are facing an 11.3 per cent hike in power rates.

He also testified he could not find any evidence of Nova Scotia Power trying to renegotiate the coal supply contracts.

Gubbins criticized Nova Scotia Power for testing pricey low-sulphur coal during a time of year when electricity demand is high and requires more coal be burned. The utility was using the coal to ensure it met environmental rules.

The utility conducted its mercury testing in November and December of 2009, which resulted in higher fuel costs and environmental emissions that were much lower than regulations required, Gubbins testified in written evidence.

"It is unclear why ratepayers should incur additional costs in 2009 on account of a requirement effective in later years," Gubbins stated in the submission.

Earlier this year, Nova Scotia Power forecast power rate hikes of 12 per cent for residential customers and 18 per cent for industrial customers, so it could buy more expensive coal with reduced mercury content as the provincial government required.

But in late July, the Dexter government softened its pollution rules to save power customers money on their power bills. It extended until 2014 the deadline for the utility to lower its mercury emissions to 65 kilograms a year from 168 kg.

The deadline extension from 2010 will reduce Nova Scotia Power’s fuel expenses by $60 million for 2011, the company says.

It is forecasting fuel costs of $544.7 million for the year.

On Monday, a proposal was put forth to phase in the power rate increase over three years, but that was rejected by Nova Scotia Power.

The hearing continues today in Halifax.

Board chairman Peter Gurnham has stated a decision would probably be made in late November.


http://www.thechronicleherald.ca/Business/1207861.html

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

NSP rejects phased-in rate hike

Utility asking review board to approve 6.5% increase in power bills next year

Nova Scotia Power rejected a proposal Monday recommended by a majority of its electricity customers to phase in a planned power rate increase over the next three years.

Senior utility executives distanced the company from any deferral of fuel costs, arguing that financial markets want the utility’s costs paid in a timely manner or it will face higher borrowing costs when it builds a wind farm.

Nova Scotia’s consumer advocate, representing the province’s 440,000 residential customers, supports the proposal so customers don’t face rate shock next year.

In the coming years, Nova Scotia Power’s customers will be faced with "significant" increases to pay for energy savings programs, higher fuel costs and capital expenses on renewable energy projects required to meet new environmental targets, said Bill Mahody.

"The compromise reached by many of the interveners properly allows for the smoothing out of fuel costs paid by ratepayers over a relatively brief period," said Mahody.

"This deferral mechanism provides NSP with an opportunity to share in the burden faced by its ratepayers while also making the company whole by the end of the deferral period."

News of Nova Scotia Power rejecting the deal came on the first day of a scheduled hearing into its application before the Utility and Review Board to hike power rates for residential customers by 6.5 per cent starting next year.

If approved by the board, it would be the sixth power rate increase in nine years in Nova Scotia.

The utility is also seeking rate increases of 8.6 per cent for commercial customers and 11.3 per cent for industrial customers. In addition, customers are facing an increase of almost three per cent on power bills starting Jan. 1 to cover the $41-million budget of setting up a new government agency to run energy efficiency programs.

"What we are concerned about is future costs for customers. . . . We truly have customers in mind when we think about future costs of financing," Brian Rendell, Nova Scotia Power’s vice-president of finance, testified Monday.

The utility requires low-cost financing as it is investing over $1 billion in renewable energy such as wind projects and tidal development, said Rick Janega, Nova Scotia Power’s chief operating officer.

Nova Scotia Power’s largest customer, NewPage Port Hawkesbury Corp., maintains double-digit power rate increases are "very troublesome" at any time but, in these "uncertain economic times," they are of even "greater concern," said NewPage lawyer David MacDougall.

He said the energy efficiency charges combined with the proposed rate increase will mean an 8.8 per cent increase for homeowners and 12.4 per cent increase for large industrial customers.

Nova Scotia Power argues that those figures are "exaggerated" and higher than its estimates.

The proposed phasing in of the rate increases was agreed to by NewPage, Bowater Mersey Paper Co. and the so-called Avon Valley group, representing businesses, as well as the consumer advocate.

MacDougall said the board has the discretion to defer power rate increases under the new method, which was approved by the board in 2009, for recovering fuel costs called the fuel adjustment mechanism.

Under the plan, an estimate of Nova Scotia Power’s base fuel costs is reset every two years and built into power rates. The estimate is later adjusted in two stages so customers pay the actual fuel costs.

Nova Scotia Power is estimating its fuel costs to be $544.7 million in 2011.

The hearing continues today in Halifax.


http://www.thechronicleherald.ca/Business/1207674.html


Saturday, October 16, 2010

New Regulations Encourage Community-Based Renewable Projects

NS Dept of Energy

October 15, 2010 9:23 AM




New energy regulations announced today, Oct. 15, will help stabilize electricity costs for Nova Scotians, while promoting a greener, more sustainable province for generations to come.

The new regulations enable the province to increase the amount of renewable electricity produced in communities across Nova Scotia, to help government achieve the goals it set in the province's new Renewable Electricity Plan.

"These regulations are another step towards implementing some of the most aggressive renewable energy goals in the world," said Premier Darrell Dexter.

"These greener, local projects will help to create good jobs, provide a better future for Nova Scotians and reduce our overall dependence on imported carbon-based sources. This will help stabilize electricity prices over the long term and improve the environment."

The Renewable Electricity Regulations follow a consultation process that determined eligible technologies and who would qualify for a community-based feed-in tariff program, which involves a fixed pricing structure for renewable electricity production.

The Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board will immediately begin the process of setting rates for community-based feed-in projects, with a hearing in the new year and a decision expected by spring.

An on-line application and approval system is scheduled to be in place in the spring. A website and preliminary guide detailing how to participate is available at www.nsrenewables.ca.

Rates will vary for developmental tidal projects and community-based projects such as small-scale in-stream tidal, run-of-the-river hydroelectricity, and biomass combined heat and power systems.

Wind projects will also face different rates -- one for projects over 50 kW and another for micro-scale projects under 50 kW. This ensures a variety of community opportunities and support development of Nova Scotia companies.

"The new regulations are an exciting step forward for Nova Scotia and it should help our company build its wind turbine business both locally and globally," said Jonathan Barry, president of Seaforth Energy. "The ability of Nova Scotians and businesses to participate in community energy will help us to scale up our operations, research and development and manufacturing and will make us more competitive globally."

"The new Renewable Electricity Regulations are very important in helping provide us with direction to move forward with the implementation of our Regional Energy Strategy for Cumberland County," said Shawna Eason, Cumberland County energy officer. "Our strategic priorities, especially wind energy development of both large scale and community projects, will benefit from the COMFIT program, helping us to increase the amount of sustainable, clean energy generated in Cumberland County."

The regulations put the Renewable Electricity Plan into action and puts Nova Scotia on course to reach its target of 25 per cent of renewable electricity supply by 2015 and a goal of 40 per cent by 2020.

The new regulations provide opportunities for combined heat and power projects, where a proponent has direct access to a biofuel source, such as sawmills, farms and greenhouses.

Medium to large-scale renewable electricity projects by independent power producers will be subject to a competitive bidding process overseen by a renewable electricity administrator who will set rates.

Talks are continuing between the province and the Mi'kmaq to encourage the development of renewable electricity projects on First Nations. The regulations are expected to be amended to incorporate agreements reached.

The province will review and analyze the progress of the Renewable Electricity Plan, with a special focus on the COMFIT program, within 18 months of implementation to determine whether the regulations are achieving its goals.

http://gov.ns.ca/news/details.asp?id=20101015002

NSP reviewing biomass decision

Utility weighing conditions imposed by utility and review board


A day after getting the government go-ahead for its proposed $208-million biomass-burning project outside Port Hawkesbury, Nova Scotia Power couldn’t say Friday if it will proceed.

Executive vice-president Robin McAdam told The Chronicle Herald that the power company is still reviewing the provincial regulator’s decision, which approved the electricity-generating project but stipulated that any cost overruns must be borne by the utility’s shareholders, not its customers.

"So, I don’t have a clear fix on that," McAdam said.

"But be assured there’s a lot of work going on."

Nova Scotia Power will not appeal the Utility and Review Board’s ruling but is studying the conditions the board imposed.

"That’s something we’re still working our way through, but I expect there’s a way to advance the project," McAdam said. "There’s a process we have to go through to carefully consider the conditions and we are doing that."

Nova Scotia Power and its largest customer, NewPage Port Hawkesbury, have been given the green light to burn 650,000 tonnes of wood waste a year for 40 years at NewPage’s Point Tupper plant, producing enough electricity for 50,000 homes.

The review board’s 50-page decision, written by chairman Peter Gurnham, includes several conditions intended to protect Nova Scotia Power’s 470,000 customers.

Gurnham wrote that the most important part of the project is a contract worth $92.9 million covering engineering, procurement and construction costs.

Any additional costs cannot be passed along to Nova Scotia Power customers, he ruled.

The board noted that Nova Scotia Power "has shown an unusual aversion to shareholder risk" in twice presenting this project to the board for approval.

McAdam was noncommittal Friday on whether the utility is prepared to shift any risk to its shareholders.

"Our job is to provide electricity at the lowest possible cost to our customers of Nova Scotia, and we are able to do that because of the kind of regulatory regime that we have here," he said.

"We work to keep the risk at the right level so we can raise money at the lowest possible cost. When we raise money at the lowest possible cost, customers benefit.

"We manage the risk profile to the best of our ability."

The board also ordered that Nova Scotia Power’s shareholders, not its customers, be on the hook if a penalty clause kicks in for a late start to the project.

Also, if there are capital cost overruns, the power company must come back before the board for another public hearing.

The board also addressed the financial woes of NewPage Corp., the Ohio parent company of NewPage Port Hawkesbury.

NewPage has reported having only $7 million in cash and $113 million available on a line of credit while being $3.3 billion in debt and facing annual debt servicing charges of $330 million.

If NewPage or its Nova Scotia subsidiary fails, no additional project costs can be passed on to Nova Scotia Power customers, the board ordered.

The utility has said it needs the biomass project to proceed in order to meet the province’s renewable energy target of generating 10 per cent of its electricity from wind, tides or biomass by 2013.


http://www.thechronicleherald.ca/Business/1207146.html

Friday, October 15, 2010

$208m biomass project gets OK


A $208-million project to generate electricity by burning wood waste in a paper mill outside Port Hawkesbury was approved with conditions Thursday by the province’s Utility and Review Board.

Nova Scotia Power and its largest customer, NewPage Port Hawkesbury, were given the go-ahead to proceed with the project at the Point Tupper mill, and they expect to burn 650,000 tonnes of biomass a year for 40 years, producing enough electricity for 50,000 homes.

Opponents say the regulatory board’s decision will clear the way for more tree-cutting in the province and increase carbon emissions.

The board’s 50-page decision, written by chairman Peter Gurnham, includes several conditions to provide safeguards for Nova Scotia Power’s 470,000 customers.

Gurnham wrote that the most important part of the project is a contract worth $92.9 million covering engineering, procurement and construction costs. Any additional costs cannot be passed along to Nova Scotia Power customers.

The board also ordered that Nova Scotia Power’s shareholders, not its customers, be on the hook if a penalty clause kicks in for a late start to the project. Also, if there are capital cost overruns, the power company must come back before the board for another public hearing.

The board also addressed the financial woes of NewPage Corp., the Ohio parent company of NewPage Port Hawkesbury. NewPage has reported having only $7 million in cash and $113 million available on a line of credit while being $3.3 billion in debt and facing annual debt servicing charges of $330 million.

If NewPage or its Nova Scotia subsidiary fails, no additional project costs can be passed on to Nova Scotia Power customers, the board ordered in its decision.

The utility says it needs the biomass project to proceed in order to meet the province’s renewable energy target of generating 10 per cent of its electricity from wind, tides or biomass by 2013.

The Ecology Action Centre of Halifax, which opposes the project, is concerned over the supply of biomass and said the review board should have waited for the provincial government’s new policy on forestry practices, expected to be unveiled later this month.

"We’re especially disappointed that this decision is going forward before the natural resources strategy is being released," said Jamie Simpson, forestry program co-ordinator for the Ecology Action Centre.

"(The new) regulations should come first, and then decide where we want to go with forest biomass harvesting."

Simpson also said the project will place a major new stress on forests and will require an extra 350,000 tonnes of clearcutting a year.

NewPage Port Hawkesbury said it was pleased with the board’s approval, especially since the board rejected a similar proposal last year.

"It’s great news for all of Nova Scotia that we are going to be able to provide a significant contribution to the generation of renewable energy in the province," said Bill Stewart, the company’s director of woodlands and strategic initiatives.

Stewart said the project will create about 150 new jobs in the seven eastern counties of Nova Scotia in trucking, harvesting and silviculture.

Port Hawkesbury Mayor Billy Joe MacLean acknowledged there is deep opposition to the project in some quarters but he said NewPage is a reputable company that will manage the forests properly.

"The company is a good community-minded company and they are the mainstay of our economic base here," the mayor said.

Independent sawmill operator Murray MacDonald, who owns or leases more than 6,000 hectares of timber in Pictou County, said the news was like a shot in the arm to the forestry industry.

"It builds confidence and it is positive news for our industry," said MacDonald, president of M.R. Holdings Ltd. "Everyone in the industry is going to benefit from this, but we must make sure to keep biomass secondary to the sawmills."

Energy Minister Bill Estabrooks applauded the review board’s decision.

"It’s important for Port Hawkesbury particularly, (and all of) rural Nova Scotia," he said.

Estabrooks also noted that Nova Scotia Power customers are protected from any risks.

With Jeffrey Simpson and Mary Ellen MacIntyre, staff reporters


http://www.thechronicleherald.ca/Front/1207046.html