Monday, July 27, 2009

Shear Wind Nearing July 30th Deadline for Response to EA Investigation

ShearWind must respond to claimed inaccuracies in their EA statement by July 30th, one of which is detailed in the most recent press release from Eco Awareness Society (see below).


~~~~~~~~~~~~~


Why is Shear Wind Afraid of Dr. Pierpont?


Dr. Nina Pierpont M.D. is a graduate of the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine. In the abstract to her upcoming book Wind Turbine Syndrome: A Report on a Natural Experiment, one reads:

“This report documents a consistent and often debilitating complex of symptoms … [that] include sleep disturbance, headache, tinnitus, ear pressure, dizziness, vertigo, nausea, visual blurring, tachycardia, irritability, problems with concentration and memory, and panic episodes associated with sensations of internal pulsation or quivering that arise while awake or asleep. The study is a case series of 10 affected families, with 38 members age <1>

In their November 27, 2008 addendum to their Environmental Assessment registration documents, Shear Wind Inc., in describing Dr. Pierpont’s work, misrepresents the maximum distance from a turbine as only 457 meters instead of 1.5 km; this is more than three times less than what the abstract states. In fact, there are seven homes closer than 1.5 km to turbines in Shear Wind’s Glen Dhu project. For this and five other statements of questionable truthfulness in their addendum, Shear Wind is under a Section 115 investigation by Nova Scotia Environment with a response due July 30, 2009.

Now, in their July newsletter to the community, Shear Wind again seeks to discredit Dr. Pierpont’s work, this time by claiming her view “that people living in proximity to wind farms may suffer from ‘Wind Turbine Syndrome’ … is not supported by scientists.” Shear Wind cites the Canadian Wind Energy website where links to seven articles authored by these scientists ostensibly support this claim. It is reasonable to expect that these authors reviewed Dr. Pierpont’s work and criticized her methods or “wind turbine syndrome” itself. However, a thorough reading reveals that five of the articles do not even mention Dr. Pierpont and only one article makes reference to her case series study stating, “One cannot discount the information.” Shear Wind is again misleading our community. While these authors do in fact “not support” Pierpont’s work, neither do they refute it, as Shear Wind would have us believe.

In contrast, Dr. Joel F. Leher, MD, F.A.C.S., one of the four doctors and scientists who, as referees, have peer reviewed the manuscript for Dr. Pierpont’s upcoming book, states, “This [report] addresses an under-reported facet of Noise Induced Illnesses in a fashion that is detailed in its historical documentation, multi-systemic in its approach and descriptions, and painstakingly and informatively referenced…. [It] opens up the area of low frequency vibration to the medical community….I applaud her.”

Based on the growing body of evidence, doctors, such as Dr. Pierpont, are calling for a minimum 2 km wind turbine setback or construction moratorium until an independent study can assess the full impact of wind turbine noise. However, as long as Shear Wind can create doubt through disinformation, our government and the general public will turn a deaf ear to such reasoned caution and Shear Wind can continue to site turbines based on financial convenience and to recklessly gamble with the health and well being of our rural communities.


Kristen Overmyer, M.S.M.E.

Baileys Brook

Friday, July 10, 2009

Some Green Collar Workers' Jobs as Intermitant as the Wind

Workers at P.E.I. wind turbine company say they haven’t been paid in eight weeks

The Canadian Press

CHARLOTTETOWN — A wind turbine maker in Charlottetown is under investigation by P.E.I.’s Labour Relations Board after employees complained they’re owed up to eight weeks of back pay.

Entegrity Wind Systems sent most of their workers home late last month after running into financial trouble.

But most of their 50 employees haven’t been paid since mid-May.

The company has not filed for bankruptcy.

Roy Doucette, director of labour and industrial relations with the Labour Department, said they are still trying to determine the status of the company.

The department issued an order this week that requires Entegrity to pay its employees.
The company has 10 days to appeal. If they don’t pay, the Labour Department will issue a judgment against Entegrity in the courts.

“We don’t know a whole lot yet, except for the fact we have employees obviously who have not been paid,” Doucette said. “We have authority to put third-party demands on monies coming into the company.”

Entegrity has offices in Charlottetown and Boulder, Colo., and a production plant in Albany, P.E.I.

http://www.amherstdaily.com/index.cfm?sid=268027&sc=508

~~~~~~~~~~~

Wind company ordered to pay back wages

CBC News

The P.E.I. Labour Department ordered a wind energy company this week to pay its employees the back wages owed to them.

Some employees who work for Entegrity Wind Systems have told CBC News their employer hasn’t paid them in weeks.

In mid-June, Entegrity told all of its 35 employees to stay home after it began to experience financial troubles.

Most of the employees affected worked in Charlottetown while some worked at a factory in Albany, P.E.I.

Malcolm Lodge, the chief technical officer with Entegrity, said the company did not see any problems beforehand.

"It happened fairly quickly and some large customers who had gone part of the way into purchases of numbers of machines scaled back their purchases," Lodge told CBC News on Friday.

"We had thought we would ride it through. We've now had to downsize the company a bit," he said.

Entegrity, which has been operating in the province since 2004, manufactures 50-kilowatt wind turbines that are suitable for small businesses and farms.

The company maintains operations in Prince Edward Island and in Boulder, Colo.

Entegrity sent a letter to its suppliers and customers in June to inform them that the economic slowdown in the U.S. has affected its overall sales.

The provincial government lent approximately $400,000 to the company. Lodge said a portion of that loan has been repaid.

Lodge said the company is currently seeking financing from both the public and private sectors so it can continue its operations.

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/prince-edward-island/story/2009/07/10/pei-entegrity-layoffs.html

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Study to determine health effects of turbines

Sarah Boesveld

From Wednesday's Globe and Mail

By now, the residents of Wolfe Island, Ont., are getting used to the whirr and thump of wind turbines overhead. By next year, they'll get a glimpse of whether those whirrs and thumps could be damaging their health.

Researchers at nearby Queen's University have embarked on the first study to probe whether wind turbines built over communities can cause adverse health effects. The study measures residents' health and well-being before the turbines arrived on the island, again when the turbines were built but not yet operational and again after they'd been operating for a few months.

People living close to turbines in other regions have reported nausea, headaches, dizziness, anxiety, sleep deprivation and tinnitus - an incessant ringing in a person's ears.

However, there has yet to be any substantive research linking those ailments to the presence of windmills, says lead study author Neal Michelutti, a research scientist in the Queen's University biology department.

"To our knowledge, this is the first time that people have acquired a snapshot of community health prior to wind turbines," he says. "It gives us [a sense of] community health that we can use in a before-and-after comparison."

The issue of health has become a lightning rod in the debate dividing communities where wind farms have been built, Wolfe Island being no exception.

While the Ontario government recently legislated a 550 metre setback for wind turbines, the 86 machines on Wolfe Island that officially hissed to life on June 26, are only 400 metres from people's homes.

Last July, Dr. Michelutti and his Queen's colleagues mailed out 1,000 SF36 surveys, a standard, multipurpose health questionnaire, to every registered address on Wolfe Island. Between 150 and 200 people returned the anonymous surveys.

On the survey, residents gave a snapshot of their general health, describing any illnesses or health problems both physical and emotional and sharing their level of physical activity and mental concentration. The researchers sent a second questionnaire asking about symptoms commonly reported by people living near wind turbines and for the residents' attitudes toward the wind project.

The same survey was completed this spring and another will be mailed in late August after the turbines have chopped the air for two months. When the third round of surveys comes back, Dr. Michelutti and his colleagues will analyze the data to find out whether community health has suffered, he says.

They plan to follow up on an annual or biannual basis for a number of years to see whether the health impacts, if any, continue to persist or crop up later. It's tricky to attribute ill health effects to turbines, without knowing a person's health beforehand, Dr. Michelutti says, which is why a before-and-after comparison is so crucial.

"A lot of these symptoms are pretty commonly reported symptoms - anxiety, sleeplessness, these sort of things," he says. "It's difficult without having that baseline data to attribute them to a specific cause and effect like the windmills."

Questions in the second survey which ask whether a respondent is for or against the wind farm may help them find out if symptoms are psychosomatic, he says.

Previous research, much of which has not been peer reviewed, links wind turbines with a variety of physical and emotional problems. Researchers in Portugal claimed the turbines contributed to "vibroacoustic disease," a full body reaction to low frequency noise that affects the auditory and vestibular system, which controls a person's ability to balance. A pediatrician in the United States coined the term "wind turbine syndrome" to describe the symptoms people experience from living near wind turbines, such as sleep disturbance, headache, vertigo, ear pressure, tachycardia (rapid heart rate) and concentration and memory problems.

Wind-farm construction has polarized communities across the country. Those in favour of wind energy say the environmental and economic benefits are plenty. Those against the farms have argued that they are annoying, disruptive and that they are harming the health of residents.

Dr. Michelutti says he and his colleagues are neutral on the issue and have not accepted funding from any anti-wind turbine groups or wind-energy development companies.

"What's important to note is no one on this study is against windmills," he says. "I think most people think windmills are great, but the question is does it make sense to build them on top of communities? Really what we're hoping our study can contribute is information on proper setbacks for the turbines."

Conducting unbiased research on the health effects of living near wind turbines is key, says Robert McMurtry, a professor emeritus at University of Western Ontario and former assistant deputy minister of population and public health at Health Canada. Such a hot button issue deserves proper tracking in order to advise on setback rates for future wind farms, he says.

"Repeating it in year two and three will really add important information to the understanding," he says. "And then if you start doing correlations between setbacks and health problems, that will be very important too."


http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/health/study-to-determine-health-effects-of-turbines/article1210357/

Monday, June 29, 2009

Digby wind project slowed

Environmental approval requires more information

PLANS TO BUILD a wind turbine park for Digby Neck hit a snag this month when Nova Scotia’s deputy minister of environment told an executive at Skypower Corp. in a letter that more information about the project is needed before an environmental assessment application is approved.



Skypower Corp. of Toronto and Scotian Windfields of Dartmouth have jointly proposed a 30-megawatt wind farm on Digby Neck comprised of 20 wind turbines, each generating 1.5 megawatts of electricity.

The proponents have said they hoped to begin construction by September, pending permits and approvals.

On June 19, deputy minister Nancy Vanstone released the decision on behalf of the environment minister. In it, she said local residents expressed concern over the potential noise from the wind farm.

"The registration document failed to provide sufficient detailed information about the proximity of nearby residents to the turbines," she said.

She asked for more details, including the number of homes, daycares, hospitals or seniors residences located within intervals of 600 metres, one kilometre, 1.5 kilometres, and two kilometres of the proposed turbines.

New information must be submitted within a year as an addendum to the original environmental assessment application, said Ms. Vanstone.

The minister would then have 50 days to make a decision, she said.

"The actual (environmental assessment application) wasn’t denied. The minister has just requested more information," said Tanya Bragg of Skypower.

She said the company plans to meet soon with environment department officials to find out what else they might require.

"We’re going to provide that to them," she said Thursday from Toronto. "We’re hoping it will not take a year."

Municipality of Digby Warden Jim Thurber said Thursday that he doesn’t know much about the request for additional information.

"I haven’t even seen (the) letter. We didn’t receive a copy of anything," Mr. Thurber said.

"In speaking with Skypower not too long ago, they had more or less told me that they were going to try and switch some of the turbines around to have all of them more than 600 metres from the closest home."

"It’s a project that...I support and I hope is able to go forward," he said.

A group of concerned residents held a public meeting last month, where it was said 20 homes were located within 700 metres of a proposed turbine, and 70 homes were found within 1.2 kilometres of a proposed turbine.

Evelyn Hayden lives in Rossway, on Digby Neck, and said she’s glad more work has to be done.

"I’m very, very pleased," she said Thursday.

Ms. Hayden said she lives 600 to 650 metres from one of the proposed wind turbines, according to information she’s seen.

"I’m glad they really took it to heart and looked at it very deeply and thoroughly," she said about the environment department.

"All we’re asking for . . . is to get these things set back away from the homes. I mean, why won’t they do it?

"At least one and a half kilometres from any building that is occupied by humans — that’s all we ask."


http://thechronicleherald.ca/Search/1129222.html


Minister's decision can be found at:

http://www.gov.ns.ca/nse/ea/digby.wind.sky.power.asp

Monday, June 22, 2009

While we hold our breath waiting for July 7th .....

.... when the RFP for small renewables are due for submission to NSPI, following are a few pieces from other places around the world. The people of the Gulf Shore are not the only ones with concerns and questions.

This is an editorial from today's East Orgegonian.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Slow down the rush of siting wind turbines in our Blue Mountains

Successive generations of children growing up in Eastern Oregon may never know we were once surrounded by an expansive and majestic landscape devoid of wind turbines. Already the foothills that display a beauty all their own are becoming something of an anomaly.

Wind turbines - and the necessity of high-voltage power lines to access the energy they produce - are the most recent threat to our Blue Mountains.

The initial step in the wind turbine issue begins Thursday, when the Umatilla County Planning Commission holds the first of several meetings to consider a local proposal to protect a chunk of our county as a viewshed (a subsequent meeting is set for July 23).

The commission's charge will be to decide whether the area is a "significant resource" to protect.

Of that, there is no doubt. That means the next steps - including an analysis of economic, environmental, energy and social impacts - will determine the future of wind turbines in northeastern Umatilla County. We ask for a slow, thoughtful process that provides a reasonable set of guidelines. Those guidelines must consider a balanced approach.

While we strongly support the environmental benefits of wind energy, we also must remember that wind is an emerging technology. There are many unanswered questions about it.

The wind isn't a consistent source of energy, for example, something highly important to energy resource managers. The wind also blows primarily at night, when energy usage is at its lowest. So, storage of electricity becomes a major issue.

Other concerns include the effect on wildlife - for example, sediment runoff from the roads necessary for the operation of the wind turbines could negatively effect salmon runs. There's also the potential harm to birds and the possible negative impact of noise on elk herds. One thing is for sure: There needs to be much more independent research on wind energy.

The rush to obtain wind turbine easements and leases by a number of new companies - including some foreign-based firms - is also a concern. Just ask some of the landowners in oil- and gas-rich states how they or their relatives were duped by wildcat well exploration drillers. There is also the troubling issue about what happens if the turbines become obsolete or are abandoned. There are many areas of this country where the extraction of coal and other natural resources have left the land scarred and almost worthless. Rusting oilfield equipment is also commonplace in the Southwest U.S.

We know contracts for wind turbine leases have provided an economic boon for some in this region at a time when it was desperately needed. Lands that offered a marginal subsistence are, at least for now, somewhat economically viable. That's important for the health of the region.

To that end, we urge a strong measure of caution as we seek to balance the short- and long-term benefits to our economy from this new source of revenue with the overarching need to preserve our viewscape now and for future generations.

Thousands of wind turbines are already marching across vast areas of Eastern Oregon - many are almost obscured from sight. Does it not make sense to continue developing out-of-sight wind farms without completely submitting our entire panorama to a parade of towering steel sentinels? After all, these are not small structures. These are massive structures - up to 400-500 feet in height. By comparison, the KOIN Center in Portland is 509 feet tall.

We wonder, in retrospect, if Celilo Falls would vanish if the decision on hydro power was being made today. Are there areas so important for their beauty they merit preservation? Could we have harnessed the potential of the Columbia River without sacrificing a natural wonder? Today, there's not an inch of Eastern Oregon where the Columbia still flows freely.

Certainly, Eastern Oregon is a resource-based economy. Our land, our timber and our water have long contributed to our well-being. We attempt to carefully use what we have to sustain our economy. It's a delicate balance between the present economy and choices that could obliterate the landscape.

We simply ask for a dose of good sense in siting decisions. While we can't totally harness the wind, we can demand a slow and thoughtful process for the placement of wind turbines in our region.

To achieve that, the county - as well as the state - should not approve random sitings without a master plan. That will require time and cooperation. The first step begins Thursday.

Unsigned editorials are the opinion of the East Oregonian editorial board, comprised of Associate Publisher Kathryn Brown, General Manager Wendy DalPez, Managing Editor Skip Nichols, News Editor Daniel Wattenburger and Senior Reporter Dean Brickey. Other columns, letters and cartoons on this page express the opinions of the authors and not necessarily that of the East Oregonian.

http://eastoregonian.com/main.asp?SectionID=14&SubSectionID=50&ArticleID=94268

Monday, June 8, 2009

Pugwash Wind Farm Dead

Last week at the candidate forum organised by the Pugwash Chamber of Commerce, Warden Keith Hunter stated that because of local opposition to a proposed wind "farm" on the Gulf Shore, it did not go ahead. He said he helped intervene on our behalf in a conversation with (then) Minister of Environment, Mark Parent.

This is in line with what representatives from Atlantic Wind Power Corp and Cobequid Area Wind Farms have stated publicly several times: that if this project was not welcome by the community, it would not go ahead.

All four candidates agreed that turbines should not intrude on the neighbouring property owners. People should be able to enjoy their properties.

They all agreed that wind energy,
along with other forms of renewable energy, is part of what we should be doing as a Province to reduce greenhouse gases but, for a variety of reasons, they should not be placed too close to homes.


Thursday, June 4, 2009

Candidates agree on wind turbine setbacks and public consultation

Candidates stage second debate

DARRELL COLE

The Amherst Daily News


PUGWASH – Residents should be consulted and their concerns answered when it comes to placing large wind farms near homes and cottages.

That was the consensus among four of the candidates seeking to be the next Cumberland North MLA during the second of two forums at St. Thomas Moore Roman Catholic Church Hall last night.

“I like windmills and we need to use more alternative energy, but we need to look at the placing of these things close to homes so they don’t interfere with people’s lives, property values and scenery,” Liberal candidate Brent Noiles said when asked his stance on promoting renewable energy and the impact of such projects on the community.

Pugwash and the Gulf Shore area were at the centre of a public controversy involving the plan by Atlantic Wind Farms to erect wind turbines near the Gulf Shore Road.

Progressive Conservative Keith Hunter, the warden of the county when it passed bylaws that would’ve allowed the turbines, said the residents of the area had a lot to do with the wind farm not going forward.

“The people fought against it and there are no windmills on the Gulf Shore,” Hunter said.

Brian Skabar, representing the NDP, said people have a right to be heard when it comes to the placement of wind turbines and said such projects must require close public consultation.

“People have a right to enjoy their property without the intrusion or the noise,” said Skabar, adding that renewable energy should play an important role in the province’s future.

Independent Ernest Fage said government regulation and public consultation will be key to preventing what residents went through in Gulf Shore.

“We need to have government regulation just like we do for other resources like the fishery and forestry,” he said.

Skabar said he’s not prepared to promise regulation until more is learned about the industry.

Responding to a question from Northport resident Joe O’Byrne on the Northport Bridge, Fage said he has been in touch with officials from the Department of Transportation and the bridge will be replaced in 2010, with design work this construction season.

“That’s the best I can tell you,” Fage said. “I have been ensured it is safe with the jersey barriers.”

Hunter said he wishes it could be replaced quicker and worries about its structural integrity, while Skabar wants the government process to be more transparent.

“If the rating goes from zero to nine and this one’s a four, I’d like to know what’s a one. What criteria is used and how is the decision made?” Skabar said.

The candidates were questioned about the beef industry and what they’d do for farmers.

Fage said red meat producers need support with a cash infusion and marketing support.

“We have to do it and it’s right to do it,” said Fage.

Hunter said he tried to support local producers when he ran his store, but found interprovincial barriers and a lack of inspectors difficult.

“You can say buy locally, but you can’t force people to do it. You need to educate people,” Hunter said, adding he’d like to see local inspection stations so small business owners can purchase and sell local products.

Skabar agreed that telling stores what they can sell goes against the spirit of free enterprise, but suggested real consultation with all stakeholders and the development of a long-term plan.

Hunter said that while large stores will be hard to convince, there are plenty of smaller stores that do purchase local.

Noiles said it’s important to keep talking on this issue.

“We have to keep talking about these things and as citizens we have a responsibility to talk about it and ask questions,” Noiles said.

Linden farmer Frank Foster said farmers are tired of having the symptoms talked about without anyone talking about a cure.

Noiles said the solution is a new government, pointing out the Conservatives have fumbled the ball while Hunter said he’s not sure if anyone knows how to save the industry.

“The best way to save it is to do what you’re doing and that’s promoting by local. You’re selling the product out there instead of going through the major chains who can’t handle it,” Hunter said.

Fage said the toughest thing with posing solutions is getting everyone pulling in the same direction including the farmers, government and retailers.

On the subject of tourism, all four candidates suggested talking full advantage of what the community has, pointing out the Pugwash Peace Exchange appears to be better known outside Nova Scotia than inside.

Green Party candidate Aviva Silburt did not attend last night’s debate.

http://www.amherstdaily.com/index.cfm?sid=257438&sc=58